Keurig Elite vs Supreme: Is the K-Elite or Supreme Plus the Best Keurig Coffee Maker?

Keurig Elite vs Supreme

In this article, we will analyze and evaluate two renowned models from Keurig’s lineup: the Keurig Elite vs Supreme

When it comes to choosing the perfect single-serve coffee maker amongst Keurig machines, it’s essential to consider both functionality and performance.

These two brewing systems in the K-Supreme series and K-Classic line have garnered immense popularity among coffee enthusiasts. Both Keurigs offer unmatched convenience with K-cups and quality brewing experiences.

As a coffee writer for Coffee Hex, I have extensively researched and tested numerous coffee machines, enabling us to provide an informed and unbiased assessment of these two Keurig models. Single-serve coffee is, after all, one of my biggest passions.

Compared to the K-Supreme, the Elite is still one of the most iconic, best machines in the market. The K-Elite falls in the Keurig K-Classic series. But the Supreme is a newer model that aims to compete for this spot. Which one’s better for you? Well, that’s what we’re about to find out. 

So, whether you’re a coffee connoisseur or a casual coffee drinker, trust us to provide you with valuable insights on the Keurig Elite vs Supreme based on your preferences. Ready to find the best single-serve K-cup coffee maker for you? Make yourself a delicious cup of coffee and let’s get started.

Keurig Elite vs Supreme At a Glance

Keurig K-Elite Coffee Maker
Keurig K-Supreme Coffee Maker
Brewing Size
Brewing Size
4, 6, 8, 10, 12 oz.
4, 6, 8, 10, 12, 14, 16 oz.
Brew Strength Control
Brew Strength Control
Temperature Control
Temperature Control
Display Screen
Display Screen
Color Touchscreen
Water Capacity
Water Capacity
48 oz.
70 oz.
Compatible Pods
Compatible Pods
Keurig K-Cup Pods
Keurig K-Cup Pods, Keurig Vue, Keurig K-Carafe
Hot Water on Demand
Hot Water on Demand
Maintenance Reminder
Maintenance Reminder
Iced Beverage Setting
Iced Beverage Setting

When comparing the Keurig Elite vs Supreme, it’s important to note that both models excel in their own right, catering to different brewing preferences and individual needs.

The Keurig Elite, with its sleek and compact design, offers simplicity and efficiency. It’s perfect for those seeking a hassle-free brewing experience with its straightforward operation and rapid brewing time. The Elite provides a wide range of beverage options—including coffee, tea, hot cocoa, and more, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

On the other hand, the Keurig Supreme takes brewing to a whole new level with its enhanced features and customization options.

Equipped with advanced programmability, adjustable temperature control, and multiple cup size options, the Supreme allows you to fine-tune your brewing process according to your personal preferences. This model is ideal for those who enjoy experimenting with different brew strengths, temperatures, and cup sizes to create their perfect cup of coffee.

Keep reading to discover the nuances of the Keurig Elite vs Supreme and explore which brewing system aligns best with your unique preferences and brewing habits. Your perfect coffee companion awaits!

Which Is Best Overall? – Comparing the K-Elite vs K-Supreme 

Brew Size

Brew size is an important consideration when choosing a coffee maker as it determines the amount of coffee you can brew in a single serving. Let’s compare the brewing size options of the Keurig Elite vs Supreme.

The Keurig Elite offers a versatile range of brewing sizes, including 4, 6, 8, 10, and 12 ounces. This provides flexibility for those who prefer different cup sizes depending on their caffeine needs or taste preferences. Whether you’re craving a quick espresso shot or a large mug of coffee to kickstart your day, the Elite has you covered with its varied brewing options.

On the other hand, the Keurig Supreme takes brewing size to the next level by offering an expanded range of options.

In addition to the brewing sizes available on the Elite, the Supreme allows you to brew 14 and 16-ounce cups as well. This is particularly beneficial for those who enjoy larger servings or prefer to fill travel mugs for their morning commute.

Winner: Keurig Supreme.

Customization Options

The ability to customize your coffee brewing experience can greatly enhance your enjoyment and allow you to tailor each cup to your specific taste preferences. Let’s delve into the customization options offered by the Keurig Elite vs Supreme.

The Keurig Elite, while focused on simplicity and ease of use, does not offer extensive customization features. It provides a straightforward brewing process without options for adjusting brew strength or temperature.

However, it still allows you to choose from a wide variety of coffee flavors and beverage options, ensuring you can find something to suit your palate.

In contrast, the Keurig Supreme takes customization to a new level with its array of adjustable settings. With the Supreme, you have the ability to control the brew strength, allowing you to select a milder or bolder cup of coffee according to your preference.

Additionally, the temperature control feature lets you fine-tune the water temperature, ensuring optimal extraction and flavor. This level of customization empowers you to create a truly personalized and satisfying coffee experience.

Winner: Keurig Supreme.

It’s no surprise: the trend for several years now seems to be toward customization. While before the main selling point was quality, it now seems to be customization. And it works. I, for one, would much rather have a coffee maker that lets me decide what good coffee is rather than decide it for me, wouldn’t you? 

Display and User Interface

The display and user interface of a coffee maker plays a crucial role in providing a seamless brewing experience and easy navigation through various settings. Let’s compare the display and user interface of the Keurig Elite vs Supreme.

Keurig’s K-Elite features a basic display that provides essential information such as brewing status and cup size selection. 

While it may not have all the bells and whistles of a high-end touchscreen display, its simplicity contributes to the machine’s overall ease of use. The straightforward button interface makes it intuitive for users to select their desired brewing size and initiate the brewing process.

In contrast, the Keurig Supreme boasts a vibrant and intuitive color touchscreen display. This feature allows for a more interactive and visually appealing user experience. 

With the Supreme’s touchscreen, you can easily navigate through various settings, adjust brew parameters, and explore additional brewing options with just a few taps. The display also provides helpful prompts and messages, making the brewing process more user-friendly.

Winner: Keurig Supreme.

The Keurig Supreme’s color touchscreen display elevates the user experience to a new level. Its intuitive interface and visually appealing design make navigating through settings and selecting brewing options effortless and enjoyable. 

Keurig K-Elite vs K-Supreme: The Winner

Alright, fellow coffee fanatics, it’s time to settle the debate between the Keurig Elite vs Supreme!

After careful consideration, I have to declare the Keurig Supreme as the undisputed winner.

With its fancy customization options, roomy internal water tank, compatibility with various coffee pods, and that snazzy touchscreen display, it’s got everything a coffee lover could dream of.

But hey, let’s not forget about our dear Keurig Elite! It’s still a solid choice if you’re looking for a compact Keurig at a lower price tag — and you just want to enjoy a reliable cup of coffee every time without all the extra frills.

So, Keurig Elite vs Supreme: Which Keurig Coffee Maker Is Your Personal Best Fit?

If you’re someone who craves simplicity and wants a no-nonsense brewing experience, the Keurig Elite coffee brewer is your go-to. It’s compact, versatile, and gets the job done without any fuss. Ideal for those who just want their cuppa hot coffee in the morning without any complications.

But if you’re a true coffee aficionado, someone who loves to tinker with brew strength, try different pods, and have all the control, then the Keurig Supreme is your coffee soulmate.

It’s like having a personal barista at your fingertips, ready to cater to your every coffee whim. Plus, that larger water reservoir means less frequent refills and more time to enjoy your caffeinated creations.

Keurig K-Supreme Coffee Maker

But if you want my humble opinion on Keurig Elite vs Supreme, it might surprise you. I’d take the Elite any day of the week.

I know by now that all of the excitement for the new features and options wears off rather quickly: at the end of the day, I’m just the same old me and I want the same old coffee. 

To get your hands on either the Keurig Elite or the Keurig Supreme, Amazon usually has the best deals. Just remember to consider your brewing style, desired features, and of course, your budget. Happy brewing, and may your coffee adventures be filled with delicious, satisfying sips!

BTW, if you’re interested in taking your Keurig on the road, check out which one we recommend for an RV in this guide.

Keurig Elite vs Supreme – FAQs

  1. How does the brew strength control compare between the Keurig K-Elite and the K-Supreme Plus?

    The Keurig K-Supreme Plus offers superior brew strength control, thanks to its Customizable Strength and Temperature settings. This allows for a more personalized brewing experience, ensuring a richer and better tasting cup of coffee. While the K-Elite also features strength control, the K-Supreme Plus’s advanced settings and Multistream Technology provide a more refined adjustment by saturating the coffee grounds more evenly, extracting more flavor and aroma with every brew.

  2. Which coffee maker has a larger water reservoir, the K-Elite or the K-Supreme Plus?

    The K-Supreme Plus features a slightly larger removable water reservoir compared to the K-Elite. This means fewer refills and more convenience, making the K-Supreme Plus a better choice for families or heavy coffee drinkers. The added convenience of the removable reservoir also makes it easier to fill and clean.

  3. Can the K-Supreme Plus brew iced coffee, and how does it compare to the K-Elite in this feature?

    Both the K-Supreme Plus and the K-Elite offer iced coffee capabilities. However, the K-Supreme Plus leverages Multistream Technology to saturate the coffee grounds more effectively, creating a stronger brew that holds up better when poured over ice, resulting in better tasting iced coffee. The customizable brewing options on the K-Supreme Plus also allow users to adjust the strength to their liking, which is particularly advantageous for iced coffee drinkers.

  4. How do the customizable temperature settings differ between the Keurig K-Elite and K-Supreme Plus?

    The Keurig K-Supreme Plus offers enhanced customizable temperature settings compared to the K-Elite, providing users with the ability to precisely adjust the temperature to their individual preferences. This capability ensures that every cup of coffee is brewed at the optimal temperature for the best flavor extraction, making the K-Supreme Plus a superior choice for coffee aficionados seeking precision and customization.

  5. Can the Keurig K-Supreme Plus be considered a smart coffee maker, and how does it compare to the K-Elite in terms of technology?

    Yes, the K-Supreme Plus can be considered a smart coffee maker, particularly the K-Supreme Plus Smart version, which offers connectivity to the Keurig app for personalized brewing. This feature allows users to create and save custom brewing preferences and even schedule brews ahead of time. While the K-Elite offers high-end features and customizable settings, it lacks the smart connectivity and app integration found in the K-Supreme Plus Smart, making the latter a more technologically advanced choice.

  6. What is the difference in cup size options between the K-Elite and the Keurig K-Supreme Plus?

    The K-Supreme Plus and the K-Elite both offer multiple cup size options, allowing users to brew various quantities of coffee, from small cups to full carafes. However, the K-Supreme Plus offers slightly more flexibility with its selection, providing up to 5 different cup sizes. This, combined with its Multistream Technology and customizable strength and temperature control, makes it possible to fine-tune the brewing process to better match individual cup size preferences and produce a more satisfying cup of coffee.

  7. Regarding maintenance, how does descaling the K-Supreme Plus compare with the K-Elite?

    Both the K-Supreme Plus and the K-Elite have an auto-off feature and are designed with removable parts to simplify maintenance and descaling. However, the K-Supreme Plus is equipped with a maintenance reminder that alerts you when it’s time to descale your brewer, ensuring your machine continues to operate efficiently. Although both models require regular descaling to maintain optimal brewing performance, the K-Supreme Plus’s reminder feature offers an added level of convenience, helping to extend the lifespan of the coffee maker.

  8. Is the Keurig K-Supreme Plus more space-efficient than the K-Elite?

    The dimensions of the Keurig K-Supreme Plus and the K-Elite are relatively similar, with both designed to be countertop-friendly. However, the K-Supreme Plus has a slightly sleeker design, which may make it appear more compact and space-efficient. Despite its larger water tank, the thoughtful design of its components, such as the removable water reservoir, ensures it takes up minimal counter space, possibly making it a slightly better option for those with limited kitchen space.

  9. Keurig K-Elite vs K-Supreme Plus: Which coffee maker should I choose for the most flavorful coffee?

    For the most flavorful coffee, the K-Supreme Plus might be the superior choice due to its MultiStream Technology that saturates the ground coffee more evenly than the K-Elite. This technology aims to extract the fullest flavor possible, making each cup of coffee richer and more robust.

  10. Which machine, Keurig K-Elite or K-Supreme Plus, offers a better water filter system?

    The K-Supreme Plus is designed with a better water filter system. It comes equipped with a Dual Position Water Reservoir and a reusable mesh filter, improving the taste and quality of your coffee by filtering out impurities from the water more efficiently than the standard water filter found in the K-Elite model.

  11. Can I use a frother with the Keurig K-Elite and K-Supreme Plus for a cafe-like coffee option?

    While neither the K-Elite nor the K-Supreme Plus comes with an integrated frother, you can easily use a separate frother with both models. For a more integrated experience, you might want to consider the Keurig K-Cafe, which comes with a built-in milk frother, providing an easy way to get that cafe-like quality coffee at home.

  12. How often do I need to refill the water reservoir in the Keurig K-Elite versus the K-Supreme Plus?

    Both models offer large water reservoirs, but the K-Supreme Plus features a 78 oz. reservoir, allowing you to brew up to nine cups before you need to refill. The K-Elite has a slightly smaller capacity, meaning you might need to fill it up a bit more frequently depending on your daily coffee consumption.

  13. Can I use ground coffee instead of K-Cup pods with the Keurig K-Elite and K-Supreme Plus?

    Yes, both the Keurig K-Elite and the K-Supreme Plus allow you the flexibility to use ground coffee instead of one of their K-Cup pods by using a Keurig reusable coffee filter. This option expands your coffee selection and gives you more control over the strength and flavor of your brew.

  14. Is there a noticeable difference in brewing speed between the K-Elite and K-Supreme Plus?

    The Keurig K-Elite and K-Supreme Plus are both designed for speed and convenience, offering rapid brewing that delivers a cup of coffee in just a few minutes. However, many users think the K-Supreme Plus heats up and brews slightly faster than the K-Elite, making it a better choice for those prioritizing speed.

  15. I’m a first-time Keurig user. Would I find the K-Supreme Plus or K-Elite easier to use?

    Both the K-Supreme Plus and K-Elite are user-friendly, designed for simplicity and ease of use. If you’re a first-time Keurig user, you’ll find clear instructions and intuitive controls on both models. The K-Supreme Plus might have a slight edge in terms of user experience due to its modern digital display which simplifies selecting brew sizes and strength settings.

  16. Is the K-Supreme Plus worth the additional cost over the K-Elite for a regular coffee drinker?

    If you’re a coffee enthusiast who values flexibility in strength settings, a larger water reservoir, and the enhanced flavor extraction offered by MultiStream Technology, the K-Supreme Plus is worth the extra investment. However, for users looking for a straightforward, reliable cup coffee maker, the K-Elite provides excellent value and high-quality coffee at a more affordable price point.

This is the heading

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet consectetur adipiscing elit dolor
limited time